Emma Tunbridge on AI, representation and resisting sameness

In the second of a two-part series, London-based advertising photographer and director Emma Tunbridge talks to Mike Owen from EIZO UK on gender, representation, the ethics and possibilities of artificial intelligence (AI), and the homogenising pressure of social-media algorithms…

Emma Tunbridge smiles as she shoots with a tethered camera on location, with crew and monitors behind her.
Emma Tunbridge on set. Photo: John Wilson

PART TWO

Beyond the frame: AI, representation and resisting sameness

The sensitivity that defines Emma Tunbridge’s work as an advertising photographer and director specialising in babies, children, families and healthcare is not confined to the relationship between photographer and subject. It extends to the wider systems through which pictures are commissioned, altered, distributed and understood.
Her answer is not to retreat into a single recognisable formula, but to play more widely: to photograph babies, children, beauty and ageing skin; to resist the demand that every image should resemble the last, and to place real bodies and lived experience back into photography’s evolving visual language.

Does being a woman give you a particular advantage when photographing children or families?

I would not describe it as a massive advantage. My assumption is that parents of any gender can understand how to work with children; it’s just that some individuals have a higher capacity for the noise and unpredictability that come with the job.

Where being a woman has clearly mattered is when a commission involves sensitive subjects connected with women’s bodies – breastfeeding, for example, or work for a continence-care brand such as TENA. Clients may deliberately seek somebody they believe will approach the situation with sensitivity.

In children’s and baby photography, being female doesn’t make much difference. Being a parent does, though: being able to share an experience with someone, to connect and speak their language. I am resistant to the idea that my gender should predetermine the work I can make or the work I get chosen for. I hope that I am seen only for my ability to connect with the subject matter. I wish photography were not gendered and that we did not need the conversation, but unfortunately, we do.

That resistance is interesting, because gender may still affect opportunity, pay and recognition even when the camera itself imposes no boundary.

It probably does. Women are often still paid less, and still tend to carry more of the responsibility for family life – not in every family, but in most. Photography competitions still reveal a disparity between different genders and ethnicities, beginning with how many people enter and how many feel that their work is worthy of being entered.

I once spoke with a competition organiser who suggested giving women an additional free entry as a way to address the gender imbalance. My immediate reaction was that it made matters worse. It treats the symptom rather than the cause. Achieving parity means helping people change their mindset: they need to feel their work has worth and will be recognised.

Yet I recognise the contradiction: I still hesitate to enter because I do not see myself or my work represented among the winners. The logical part of my brain asks why I should pay an entry fee if the work is likely to fall on deaf ears. Representation affects confidence, and confidence affects participation.

The structure of photographic work can deepen that divide, particularly during the years when people raise families.

Absolutely. Long film projects may involve ten or twelve weeks of 14- to 16-hour days. That pattern does not readily facilitate family life. Somebody usually has to be at home taking responsibility for everything else.

You can see an obvious gap among women in parts of the industry. There are younger women and older women, while the child-rearing generation becomes less visible. A young photographer may gain experience on five films, take a career break, then return in her forties without anything like the portfolio of peers whose careers continued uninterrupted.

It isn’t simply a question of gender; it’s more complex than that. It affects every family in some way. Often one person takes on more of the work while the other focuses on home, and some families balance it by taking turns: ten years of one career, then the other gets a chance. There are ways of rebalancing, and we are getting there.

But it always comes at a cost. Photography is competitive, and after years of prioritising it above everything and putting in long hours, stepping back is difficult. For all the joys of looking after a family, you may start missing commissions, which become missing experience and opportunity. The inequality compounds itself, and the lost time feels hard to make up. And it isn’t only parenting that affects careers: it can be caring for others, or our own health. Photography and directing are freelance careers, so taking time out is difficult, and that can be unforgiving. I keep striving for a balance between family, self-care and work, and that search works its way into the stories I tell and deepens the narratives I create with clients.

A mother holds her newborn close post feed bathed in pink and blue light of the low nighttime nightlights.
Photography: Emma Tunbridge

At the same time, artificial intelligence is beginning to remove some lower-budget work altogether. How do you view that change?

The position is complicated. There are jobs for which clients may decide they no longer need to fly samples around the world, manufacture prototypes and bring a large team together. AI may appear cheaper and, in some cases, environmentally preferable at first glance – although we now know that generative systems carry their own enormous environmental cost.

What is unsettling is the sense that photographers cannot control the change happening to photography’s visual language. It is not simply creative professionals choosing to use a new tool. People outside the industry can now enter the creative process through that door without understanding the ethical implications.

It’s very easy for a finished photograph to be put into a generative system with a request like, “Can you retouch it like this?”, without anyone stopping to ask the photographer or the model. Nobody means any harm. If the platform is not a closed system, the model’s face and biometric data may have been absorbed, along with my authorship and visual style. To the person uploading it, it is merely a photograph. They may have no conception that consent, copyright and personal data are involved. By the time the question is raised, the upload has already happened.

That tension must be particularly sharp because you are also fascinated by the technology.

Completely. The technology is mind-boggling, and I can see the joyful, extraordinary things it could enable. I am excited by its creative potential.

But it has a darker side that cannot be ignored. The systems were trained using the work of photographers, writers, artists and illustrators without meaningful permission or remuneration. You can ask for imagery in the manner of a well-known photographer and receive something remarkably close to their work.

So, I feel blocked from playing with a tool that fascinates me because it is built from material gathered in ways I cannot accept. There are unresolved questions too. If the law eventually provides compensation for creators whose work was used in training, would deliberately feeding my images into AI jeopardise my claim? Nobody can give a clear answer.

That uncertainty consumed a great deal of mental space last year. Commissions slowed sharply across the industry. It was easy to blame everything on AI, but looking back, I don’t think it’s that simple. It was a wider climate of uncertainty. People quickly stopped believing that the image or film in front of them was real, and any artistry was overshadowed by the doubt that it might have been generated rather than crafted. For a while, two decades of learning light and composition, of layering meaning into my work, seemed to carry less weight, because the first thing a viewer did was question its authenticity. At the time, that fear was overwhelming. I think that’s shifting now, and we’re seeing a strong pushback from audiences. Brands will always need ways to reach people that are verifiable and tangible, and real images of real people are part of that.

How did that fear affect your photography?

I lost my path for a while. I sat at my desk asking whether the work I was making would remain useful, whether I should learn to work with AI, whether I was spending my time correctly and what would happen if the career into which I had poured more than 20 years disappeared.

Every significant decision in my adult life had been made around my love for this medium and this job. If that vanished, what would I be? What would I do next? I began constructing backup plans in my head.

All that thinking occupied the brain space in which play and experimentation should have happened – the building blocks of my personal work had no room to grow.

But I think all artists have those moments for one reason or another. Perhaps it’s necessary. I have restarted my personal work, and it is stronger than ever. Freer in a way, more playful and more abstract. What I can see clearly is that this period will strongly shape the kind of art that gets made. It will be a direct reaction to the change and uncertainty we’re living through, and I’m fascinated to see what comes of it and to play my part in it. The visual language never stops, and I want to continue to move it forward in a positive way without fear. We are in a transitional phase, and the job will quite likely change. My purpose now is to take joy in being part of that change.

A mother sits on a wooden stool against a warm red backdrop, holding her baby close against her body.
From Parere, Emma Tunbridge's personal project about the bodies that bring forth and hold our children. [Model: Zara]

Photography has already moved from analogue to digital and from DSLR to mirrorless. Do you see AI as another technological transition?

People were frightened when analogue gave way to digital, just as societies have feared other transformative technologies. Adoption is rarely as quick as it first appears. Digital photography took time to become dependable and useful across every professional application.

Generative AI is still remarkably uncontrollable. It is not reliably replicable. The same prompt produces a different result; asking it to move somebody slightly or change one colour can transform the entire picture. You may reach an almost perfect result, ask for a minor adjustment and never find your way back.

Those limitations will improve. It would be silly to pretend otherwise. The deeper question is what kind of creative culture we build around the technology and what we protect as it develops.

What, then, remains uniquely important about human image-making?

Real people working together produce something I could never fully anticipate, however much research, planning and shoot decks come before the day. Every member of the team brings a creative brain and context that strengthens the idea. The final image is richer because it includes those contributions.

AI works through probability and through what it has already encountered. It can combine, project and guess, but it cannot live inside the randomness of human experience. It does not feel the shift in a room, understand why a particular person suddenly responds, or recognise the unplanned gesture that changes the whole picture.

Photography and motion are not only the output. It is the encounter that produces them: the trust, the play, the conversation, the accident and the intelligence moving between people. That is the tangible, real element I want to invest in.

Emma Tunbridge smiles as she shoots with a tethered camera on location, with crew and monitors behind her.
Emma Tunbridge on set. Photo: John Wilson

You have also become concerned about the synthetic material appearing in social-media feeds.

We are served AI-generated reels with no labelling, often little more than clickbait designed to keep us on the platform. They can perform extremely well, and I suddenly find myself thinking: what am I watching? It was questionable enough to spend time watching somebody’s pet; now it may be a computer-generated pet that never existed.

It is an entirely artificial pull on our concentration. We reach for the feed because we want rest or escape, then run straight into the very technological anxiety we were trying to get away from. It becomes a feedback loop.

Human beings need creativity, but we also need long-form creativity – the ability to concentrate on something for more than 20 seconds. Platforms are designed to keep feeding us more, and that is not healthy for the brain.

My seven-year-old daughter is delighted by the idea that social media might be restricted for children. She imagines that by the time she has a phone, perhaps she will not have to worry about TikTok. She barely understands what those platforms are, but she already understands the cultural narrative that they can be harmful. I find that both sobering and strangely hopeful.

Close-up of an older woman's lower face and neck, her finely lined skin lit by soft natural light.
From At My Age, Emma Tunbridge's personal project on ageing skin and the writing of time across the body.

How does representation fit into your wish to create a healthier visual world for her generation?

It became very clear to me when I began photographing ageing skin. A child looking at advertising, magazines, billboards or a feed will predominantly see people in their twenties, perhaps their thirties. People in their forties become scarce and bodies over 50 can appear almost not to exist.

What is she supposed to feel about herself at 30, 40 or 50 if she has never been shown what those ages look like? Human bodies change shape and colour. Things protrude, crease and shift. If we are going to live long lives, that is a great many years to spend feeling unhappy or unrepresented.

Why should somebody approaching middle age look at themselves and think, “This is not how I should look,” when the only comparison they have been offered is a 20-year-old? Of course they do not look 20. The extraordinary thing is that they are healthy, present and alive. Skin tells stories about experience.

My aim is to put that good material back into our visual language: real bodies, different ages and narratives that help people feel understood. Photography can show joy, but its documentary honesty also creates acceptance. It says: I am not the only one.

Algorithms reward recognisable consistency, while creative work depends upon discovery. How do you negotiate that conflict?

Photographers are repeatedly told to define their “why”, build personal work upon what they already have and avoid posting anything too unexpected because clients need to understand what they are buying. Choose one thing, repeat it, make people feel safe, and perhaps they will commission you. I absorbed that advice for so many years that I stopped playing. It created my own echo chamber.

This year I am deliberately returning to the more playful scattergun approach. I’m looking at stories rather than specific ages, and seeing where they take my work. Wherever it goes, it all comes from the same place: real people, real bodies and real moments. I am not going to worry about whether every image belongs in the portfolio, but rather what I bring to the story and how I can share it in a new way – one that resonates with how we all feel now. My motion work is deepening too, with longer narratives and more ambitious structures. There is so much to experiment with.

My visual language must evolve in response to my experiences. If I only feed it material that resembles what I have already made, I cannot produce newness. I need to shoot in different directions, bring everything back, look at it, filter it and allow the threads to weave themselves together.

There is an obvious commercial tension. Social platforms reward continuity and clients need clarity, but the industry ultimately depends on creativity. Instagram may present itself as a creative platform, yet its algorithm wants sameness because sameness is easy to categorise and serve. The photographer’s task is to resist becoming an algorithm of oneself.

A woman with long, wet dark hair looks down over her bare shoulder, her face partly covered in pale clay.
Photography: Emma Tunbridge.

Finally, what do you want the next stage of your career to look like?

More play! I want to put my energy and time into the teams around me, into real creative thinkers and personal projects, and into telling the stories of actual human beings, in stills and film. I want to be present in the moment and able to feel it.

That does not mean ignoring change or romanticising the past. Photography has always evolved. It means deciding what should survive the transition: consent, curiosity, sensitivity, unpredictability and the pleasure of people creating together.

It is a strange, exhausting and highly entertaining time to be alive. But fear cannot be the purpose. The purpose is to make, to play and to put something truthful and positive back into the visual world.

EmmaTunbridge Headshot landscape uai

Emma Tunbridge

Emma Tunbridge is a London-based advertising photographer and director working in stills and motion, specialising in babies, children, families and healthcare. See more of her work at www.emmatunbridge.com or on Instagram @emmatunbridge.

Read Part One of this interview: here


Back to Spotlight

Other articles you may like